Skip links

Why Are My Leads Bad? Start With Lead Response Time

CATEGORY:

Lead Generation

Bad leads are one of the many common reasons businesses start looking for marketing help. A home services company might get plenty of calls and form fills, only to find that too many come from people outside its service area, job seekers, or homeowners shopping for supplies to do the repair themselves. Other times the leads are solid and slip away before anyone calls them back. That’s why the first step is figuring out which one you’re dealing with.

We asked Allie Schroeder, our Marketing & Account Director, and Melissa Morrison, our Digital Marketing Manager, how they figure out whether a business has a lead quality problem or a follow-up problem, and what to do about each.

Why Do Sales and Marketing Disagree About Lead Quality?

Usually because marketing and sales are using two different definitions of a good lead. “Marketing thinks it’s a good lead if they filled out a form or called,” Allie says. “Sales may only think it’s a good lead if they are ready to sign now at full price.” Sometimes the verdict on lead quality comes from a feeling instead of the numbers. A few frustrating calls in a row, like someone asking for a service you don’t offer or a prospect who never calls back, can make the whole month feel like a bust. Those calls stick with you more than the ordinary ones that turned into appointments. Looking at the full list of leads is how you find out whether the bad ones are the rule or the exception.

How we review a new client’s leads

Allie’s first step with a new client is to go back through the last 25 to 50 leads and mark each one as good, bad, or OK but didn’t close. If the client tracks where their leads come from, she sorts them by channel and campaign too. That’s where patterns show up, like one campaign sending in most of the bad leads while another sends the ones that close.

Going through the leads one by one also shows what happened after each one came in. Did someone return the voicemail? Did anyone reply to the form, and how long did it take? A lot of the time, a lead that looks bad on paper was a good one that waited too long to hear back. “If you’re a home service business, or you have a client who needs a machine part in a rush, a lead that was warm at 10 a.m. today is ‘bad’ in 24 to 48 hours,” Allie says, “because they’ve already moved on to the next source on their shortlist.”

If bad leads outnumber the good ones, that points to targeting. Calls and forms from outside your service area mean the geography needs adjusting. People asking for a service you don’t offer usually means the search terms or ad creative are too broad or confusing.

How Fast Should You Respond to a New Lead?

As soon as possible.

Phone calls come first. Someone who calls is ready to talk to a person right now, and answering promptly is the best first impression you can make. If you miss the call, they might leave a message, but they’re also likely dialing the next business on their list.

Form fills work the same way. The person is researching options, and the sooner you respond, the more likely you catch them while they’re thinking about a solution or a purchase. When you can’t respond right away, Allie recommends an automated email that confirms the form came through and says what to expect. Let the person know if a reply will take 24 hours. And if the next step is a call from a customer service rep, tell them that too.

Why home service leads go cold faster than B2B leads

Home service businesses have an extra challenge: plenty of homeowners do their research on evenings and weekends. “If you are only answering phones or scheduling appointments Monday through Friday, a lead that comes in Friday at 8 p.m. for a leaking roof is bad by Monday morning,” Allie says. “They already found someone else.” Even if your crews only work weekdays, answering the phone and returning messages on weekends gives you a shot at those jobs.

B2B buyers are a little more forgiving. Speed still counts, because a fast response is an early sign of good customer service. It can give you the edge over a competitor who took a week to send a quote.

Do You Have a Lead Quality Problem or a Follow-Up Problem?

Check follow-up first. It’s the fastest thing to check, and there’s no point adjusting your targeting if good leads are slipping away.

When we bring on a new client, we start by meeting with their sales team to understand the sales process, including how follow-up works. From there, Allie looks at a few things:

  • CRM timestamps. How long did a form sit before someone reached out, and did it get a response at all?
  • Call tracking. How many calls were missed or went to voicemail?
  • A test run. We submit a form and sometimes make a phone call ourselves to see what a customer experiences.
  • Call recordings. Within a few calls, patterns start to show up.

Those recordings usually settle the question. “It’s a follow-up problem if they are calling about a service you offer, in your service area, and the call ends with no next steps,” Allie says. “It’s a lead quality problem if it’s a service you don’t offer or they are located in a state you don’t serve.”

For consumer-facing businesses, it’s after-hours calls that don’t get returned promptly, or at all. In B2B, it’s leads that sit untouched because they were never assigned an owner. And in both, website forms sometimes aren’t being delivered to the right inbox.

How Do You Filter Out Junk Leads From Paid Ads?

When Melissa reviews what’s been running for a new client, she’s looking for the leads that never had a chance of becoming customers: DIY questions, job seekers, and people outside the service area. Most of those can be screened out before anyone has to answer the phone.

Google Ads and Microsoft Ads search campaigns

Negative keywords do most of the work here. Before a campaign serves a single ad, Melissa adds a starting list of negatives that includes terms like jobs, hiring, internships, employment, free, discount, DIY, definition, research, and training. States outside the target area go on the list, too.

She reviews search terms every week, since those show exactly what people typed before they saw an ad. With phrase match keywords, Google shows ads for the keyword and for searches it considers similar. An ad for “roofers near me” might show up for “roofing supplies near me.” Adding “supplies” as a negative keyword stops the ad from showing for any search that includes it.

Location settings matter as well. Google offers two options:

  • Presence or interest: people in, regularly in, or who’ve shown interest in your target locations
  • Presence: people in or regularly in your target locations

Melissa almost always uses Presence. With the other setting, someone can see your ad from outside the country as long as they’ve shown interest in your area.

Google Local Services Ads

Local Services Ads work differently. Leads are calls or messages for the services you list, with no keywords or website involved. Google uses AI to screen calls, and it won’t charge for (or will refund) a lead that’s poor, like someone following up on an estimate that’s already scheduled, asking about a service you don’t offer, or looking for a job.

That screening isn’t 100% accurate. Melissa or someone on the client’s team listens to the calls and rates them, which helps the system learn which leads are best and keeps the business from paying for the ones that aren’t.

How to Check Your Own Leads

Pull your leads from the last 30 to 90 days from wherever they live, whether that’s a CRM, an inbox, or a call log. Then go through each one and ask:

  • Did they ask for a service you offer?
  • Are they in your service area?
  • Was it spam?

If a lead passes all three, it’s a real lead, and your leads are probably better than you think. Next, look at what happened after each one came in:

  • Did someone reach out to them?
  • How long did that take?
  • Did they get a quote or book an appointment?
  • Did they become a customer?

Finally, look at your best customers and figure out how they found you. A CRM tracks this for you, following each lead from the first call or form fill through the closed sale. Without one, you can ask “How did you hear about us?” on your forms and over the phone, but the answers depend on someone remembering to ask and write it down, and on the customer remembering how they found you. Treat it as a stopgap until you have a system that tracks it automatically.

What Tools Keep Leads From Going Cold?

Spreadsheets only tell you something when someone remembers to update them. The right tools show you what’s happening with your leads as it happens:

  • Call tracking shows when calls come in, where they came from, and which ones were missed. That alone can be a wake-up call for a business that assumed every call was being answered.
  • CRM alerts go to the person responsible for a lead as soon as it comes in, and reminders prompt follow-ups.
  • Automated texts and emails help when you’re juggling several leads at once. For example, an email two days after your first call can ask if they have questions and invite them to schedule the service or next meeting.

None of these can close a deal on their own. An automated reply can remind someone about your offer, but it can’t tell you why they aren’t ready to buy. Alerts only work if someone acts on them, and Allie has seen teams set up so many that they start tuning them out. “Tools should be used to help you get to the right lead,” she says, “but the most successful salespeople are still the ones building relationships with their customers.”

How Should Sales and Marketing Share Lead Information?

Sales and marketing get a lot more effective when they work from the same information. When sales reports which leads closed, marketing can trace where those leads came from and put more effort there.

That starts with a shared CRM where every lead has an owner and a status. A platform like HubSpot can track each lead automatically from the first touch to the closed deal, with no spreadsheets to reconcile at the end of the month. Add a regular check-in where sales shares what they’re hearing from prospects and marketing shares what it’s seeing in the data. “When both teams are looking at the same numbers,” Allie says, “they stop blaming each other and start working on what to change.”

Swap the Spreadsheet for a CRM

If Allie could get every business owner to do one thing, it would be to get off spreadsheets and invest in a CRM. A CRM shows you which leads are good, who’s following up, and how quickly, which is everything you need to answer “Are my leads bad?” with facts.

Holland Adhaus helps businesses set up HubSpot so sales and marketing work from the same numbers. Our digital advertising team reviews search terms every week and listens to Local Services Ads calls, so you stop paying for leads that were never going to buy. If you’re not sure whether you have a lead quality problem or a follow-up problem, talk with our team or call 513.744.3000.

Level Up Your
Lead Response Time

Connect